|
A while ago I read a small part of this in some magazine, I can't remember which one, and thought it sounded really good. Billy Burns, called the American Sherlock Holmes, is called into service, to discover the perpetrators, and bring them to justice.Clarence Darrow, DW Griffith, Mary Pickford, and others are all a part of this story.Anarchists, water wars, unions vs. This was a terrific book. An amazing story, real people, and the fact that it is all true, made it even better.
Showmanship, and theater in the courtroom played out, much like what we see on Court TV. non-union men, were all suspected in the bombing. The men who actually did the bombing, had done over 100 bombings across the country.Burn's life was threatened, more than once. Movies were made about each side of the case, while the case was ongoing.I learned alot from this book, most interestingly, that Edgar Lee Masters, one of my favorite authors, was a law partner of Clarence Darrow. Scandal, bribery, and violence were all part of the trial, and at the conclusion, there was a surprise. I was right.
It turned out to be the leaders of the unions, "suggesting" non-union places to bomb. It really showed that there is a big difference, then as today between justice for the rich and famous, and justice for the everyday man.The whole story was intriguing, and a very sad part of American history.I got this book from the Library. Howard Blum has written a narrative nonfiction book that is one of the best I have read. October 1, 1910 the LA Times building was blown up, killing 21 and injuring many others.
The issue of labor in the country and Los Angeles is an eye opener. I enjoyed it. I love reading histories of the twenties and Darrow is a personal hero.
Burn's investigation however is fun to follow. I think this book gives the reader an easy and interesting way to open period of history and then one can go on to other history books for more information. Other reviewers have criticized the narrative style of the book.
I was drawn to Howard Blum's book AMERICAN LIGHTNING when I read that Clarence Darrow was involved. "Billy" Burns, American's greatest detective and brilliant legal mind, Clarence Darrow, both ignore lots of Constitutional guarantees, this was the biggest eye opener of the book.
This part of his life tarnishes the image a little.The book is about the bombing of the Los Angeles Times building and the investigation. The two protagonists, William J.
Daniel Stashower's The Beautiful Cigar Girl takes a similiar celebrity artist/true crim connection, mining a real-life NY murder and Edgar Allan Poe's fictionalization to much more dramatic result. Many of the social dynamics here explored were better studied in Watson's Sacco and Vanzetti. There is no shortage of good material in what has been a fertile historical period for literature recently.Mike Dash's work is superior on true crime - as is Larson's in both Devil and Thunderstruck.
The central conflict in Blum's set-up is the labor versus capital tension that escalated from striking and strike breaking to the bombing that serves as the book's central narrative. Overall, there are just much better reads out there unless you really want to hone in on this crime, this city, or these historical figures. Not a lot to add to some of the other critical reviews of this book as I agree that the Burns/Griffith/Otis narrative was scattershot and made for a lot of extraneous material.One point I have not seen in other reviews that I would expound upon is Blum's clear bias, which - for me - made the book less enjoyable from the beginning.
In fiction or in historical nonfiction, I would look elsewhere for a capsule of this rocky time period at the turn of the century, only forty years removed from the Civil War and in the midst of America's fitful rise to the global power that it would cement in WWII. In fiction, Lehane's The Given Day is a Boston-based look at the same period and in many ways the same idiom. As he lays out this conflict, he is unsparing in his criticism of Otis, his trade association and his allies.
While they are "uncompromising," the LA Times' writing is "shrill and unyielding," and their actions to break strikes are "brutal." By contrast, the union leaders are possessed of "strident minds," Griffith's work embodies "the workingman's struggle to put a loaf of bread on his dinner table." Where Otis is "intransigent" and "belligerent," union leader Olaf Tveitmoe is "fierce," "formidable," and "intellectual."But, that is just one element.
Highly recommended for those who want to learn more about this interesting place in history without relying on dense academic tomes. By no means an academic read, this book succeeds in being a engaging trip through a fascinating time in the history of Los Angeles and, on a broader scale, America.
I never really found it to be a "page-turner," in that there was not really a point in the book which I was eager to flip to the next chapter anxiously awaiting the next development. This setup actually is quite reminiscent of the way the earlier suspense movies are arranged, probably quite deliberately.While the book has several engaging sections, I found the pace of the book to be somewhat slow and dragged out at points. The chapters often stops at points which you just want to put the book down instead of flipping to the next section, and moments that the author could have used to build up suspense instead got side-tracked to character thoughts, thereby leading to a loss in momentum of the story.While not a bad read, for me this book lack excitement, especially with such title. The centerpiece of this novel revolves an explosive crime that took place in California (and later, other cities too), and follows a detective's attempt to track down the suspects while navigating through the political plays. The structure of the story is set up nicely: the scenes flips back-and-forth between the multiple locations, different players with vested interest in the case, and the detective's thoughts.
|